Where to Buy Gold Near Me in Columbus, OH – Best Places to Buy Gold Bars, Gold Coins & Bullion
Best Rated Sponsor
Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry
ADDRESS: 190 Graceland Blvd, Columbus, OH 43214, United States
NUMBER: +1 614-846-4653
DESCRIPTION FROM BUSINESS: Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry is a locally owned and operated buyer and seller of gold bars, gold coins, diamonds, and precious metals in Columbus, Ohio. Owners Steve Fagin and Dwight Nippert have set out to create a business that puts its customers first, always. Visit the Graceland store today!
OFFICE HOURS
| Mon | 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM | |
|---|---|---|
| Tue | 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM | |
| Wed | 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM | |
| Thu | 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM | |
| Fri | 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM | |
| Sat | 10:00 AM – 3:00 PM | |
| Sun | CLOSED |
>>> BEST CUSTOMER REVIEWS
REVIEW #1 – I highly suggest this coin shop. I had some gold bars and coins to sell and got a very fair value along with great customer service from Sean. I will return to this shop in the future to sell/buy gold bars/coins. Thank you Buckey gold & coin! – Brent Rosen
REVIEW #2 – I had an excellent first-time experience. Shaun, the manager, was extremely professional and helpful throughout the process. The transaction was smooth, and I left feeling confident and satisfied. Highly recommend this location and team—I will definitely be a returning customer. – lang hawj
REVIEW #3 – Doing business with BGCJ was a great experience. Store manager Anthony was very knowledgeable and the surcharge was very reasonable for buying my 10 oz silver bars. They also have the same silver coins that are issued from the US Mint, but no big mark up or shipping costs. I highly recommend doing business with them. – Albert Milner
REVIEW #4 – I visited this establishment recently. I was greeted warmly, and treated like royalty. Anthony took care of me quite well. This will most likely be my go to place for my gold needs in the future. – Chris Hannon-Jones
REVIEW #5 – Anthony DiMuzio at Buckeye Gold Coin and Jewelry was great to work with. Very fair pricing (and I looked around quite a bit) friendly and very helpful! ) Great inventory as well for very cool gifts of coins and jewelry. I will be back! – Laura Hosmer
REVIEW #6 – Stopped in to get some jewelry I’ve had for a while now valued. Sean Donovan helped me out and he was awesome. Very friendly and professional. All and all it was a great experience. Highly recommend! – Tiffany Paige
Recommended Sponsors
GoldenCrest Metals: Offering a FREE Guide for Those Looking to Buy Gold Bars or Silver
Noble Gold Investments: Buy Gold Coins & Gold Bullion Bars At Great Prices
GoldenCrest Metals: Looking to Buy Gold Near Me? Check Out Our Free Guide
>>>MORE CUSTOMER REVIEWS
REVIEW #1 – When my mother passed away, I had to deal with a ton of stuff in her house, most of which had very little value and needed to be donated or thrown away. When my wife found her old jewelry collection, it appeared to also mostly be cheap stuff that would be difficult to sell. Anthony and company did a great job finding the stuff with varying gold content and silver pieces and gave us a fair price that actually shocked us and helped pay for the expenses of preparing my mother’s house for sale. Buckeye Gold made the process of dealing with my mother’s estate so much easier and reduced the stress and burden I have been dealing with since she passed away. Thanks so much! – Bob Dobalina
REVIEW #2 – I’ve been visiting here for about a year now and always get the best customer service. I frequently come in with questions about coins or rings or anything else and leave with all my questions answered. Today Sean Donovan gave me a couple of half dollar coin flips for free and talked to me about large cents for a while even though I didn’t buy anything, very nice guy. – Jimmy Kerr
REVIEW #3 – I Went in to liquidate some gold bars. Anthony was very fair and the whole process was very transparent. Buy and sell prices were the standard spread and I was informed of the retail value and the offered buy price before agreeing to the transaction. Everything was above board & honest and I will go there again. – Roger Lehman
REVIEW #4 – My wife and I went in to sell some of her gold jewelry and I know we got a really good payout. The store manager Anthony took the time to inspect all of the pieces and was very straight forward and efficient with us. I will definitely recommend bringing any jewelry to Buckeye Gold. It’s really the best decision you could make. – Brandon Ferguson II
REVIEW #5 – Went in on a Saturday at the Graceland location to check out what all was available. The employee working, Brandon Hord, was very knowledgeable and helpful and helped me pick out a great custom gold coin for a decent deal. Great place to do business, thank you Brandon and Buckeye Gold! – Dakota Chaffee
REVIEW #6 – This was my first time visiting this location, and even though I haven’t made a purchase yet, I wanted to leave a review because of how helpful Sean Donovan was. He took the time to answer all my questions and explain things clearly, without ever making me feel rushed or pressured to buy anything. I’ve stopped into a few of their shops before, and every time Sean has been consistent—knowledgeable, professional, and genuinely kind. It’s rare to meet someone who is both patient and passionate about what they do, and Sean makes the whole experience welcoming. I’ll definitely be coming back. – Alex Kelley
REVIEW #7 – I am a 48 yr old Female, I went to Buckeye Gold Coin and Jewelry in Graceland Shopping center today on a recommendation from an acquaintance. I wanted to move along some silver and gold jewelry pieces that I did not wear anymore. Anthony was professional and paid me by weight = $830.00. That helps the poketbook! I did not sell anything sentimental, I am pleased with my experience at Buckeye Gold Coin and Jewelry; I will go back! – Amanda Hubbs
REVIEW #8 – I actually compared the offer w another reputable jewelry store and this store was just a couple dollars more. But even that amount, albeit very minimal, showed me that they can be trusted. It’s easy to find. Quick to help. Fast process after the first transaction. – Aimee Lilly
REVIEW #9 – Extremely friendly and knowledgeable staff that are well versed in precious metals, paper money, rare coins and jewelry. I’ve only had great experiences here and they have always given me great deals whether I’m buying or selling. Great selection on jewelry and bullion. Anthony is always happy to help and gets me the best prices possible. – Aria Nonya
REVIEW #10 – Went to Buckeye Gold to sell some old jewelry, and would strongly recommend this location to anybody in search of somewhere to sell metal items. We chose this location due to the great reviews, and they really do hold up. I walked in not entirely sure what exactly I had or what it was worth, but James made the process stress-free! He was incredibly informative, and was able to tell me which items weren’t what I had previously thought. He was quick yet attentive in examining my items, and gave a very fair price for the items worth selling. The speed and ease of the process went beyond my expectations as a first-time seller for sure. Should I ever sell similar items in the future, I wouldn’t even think twice before returning to Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry! – Dori Moore
REVIEW #11 – Went to the Pickerington store to sell some gold and Derek Hanna was really great to work with. Honesty and integrity goes a long way with me. His offers double that of a local company that I frequent!! I’ll highly recommend Buckeye Gold as it was recommended to me. – Crystal Wingo
REVIEW #12 – I went in upset because a pawn shop said my bracelet was only 14k gold when I thought I purchased 18k, and 18k was engraved on it. I called prior and Anthony was very helpful. He retested the gold and told me they were wrong and it was actually 18k. Trust is hard to come by these days. If you don’t want ripped off, make sure you choose this store. – Francesca Behrmann
REVIEW #13 – Honestly first time coming in looking for something very niche, they happened to have it. Transaction took less than 3 minutes to find, purchase and leave. Very nice selection of fine jewelry and coins. fair prices as well, will return and highly recommend. – James Breneman (JD Cringe)
REVIEW #14 – Good experience, would go back in the future. Anthony was knowledgeable and gave helpful suggestions for a ring that I’d like to sell or repurpose, and prices paid for other gold jewelry was very fair. – Theresa Fruner
REVIEW #15 – I was in the other day just browsing and Anthony helped me. He was incredibly professional and genuine. I let him know I wasn’t planning on spending money that day but he was just as accommodating as if I had American Express black card. I will definitely be coming back and look forward to spending my money at business that made me feel so welcome. – Emma Hirst
REVIEW #16 – I was so impressed with Anthony DiMuzio, the store manager at the Buckeye Gold located In the Graceland shopping center. I had several concerns about some coins and vintage silver that I had purchased online. Anthony was extremely helpful in answering the concerns I had. Even though I didn’t sell my items, I know we will do business in the future. Anthony’s kindness and willingness to help is much appreciated. – Linda Long
REVIEW #17 – Brandon was so helpful with my coin sales today. Buckeye gold is always my go to for all my gold and coin sales. They are very fair and knowledgeable. – Meechy Stephenson
REVIEW #18 – Went in with my mother to sell a bit of silver and to have a decent sized coin collection valued. The store manager Anthony DiMuzio is very efficient and knowledgeable about his craft!
Very quickly knew what would and wouldn’t be worth much and managed to go through many coins quickly. He also showed us a couple high value coins he has in the store.
We’ll likely be heading back with some gold once we gather it up. Overall great experience, can’t recommend it enough! – Kevin Shannon
Recommended Sponsors
BullionStar: Legally Buy Gold Bars & Silver with NO TAXES
Money Metals Exchange: Great Place to Buy Gold Coins and Gold Bullion Bars
Silver Gold Bull: Excellent Place for Those Wondering Where to Buy Gold Near Me
